FREE! Click here to Join FunTrivia. Thousands of games, quizzes, and lots more!
Quiz about Swing from a Dangling Participle
Quiz about Swing from a Dangling Participle

Swing from a Dangling Participle Quiz


Dangling participles and other misplaced modifiers will challenge you here! I've used examples from published grammarians, plus instances from newspapers and classic film. U.S. Standard Written English applies. Take a swing, but beware!

A multiple-choice quiz by gracious1. Estimated time: 6 mins.
  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Quizzes
  4. »
  5. Humanities Trivia
  6. »
  7. English
  8. »
  9. Grammatical and Lexical Items

Author
gracious1
Time
6 mins
Type
Multiple Choice
Quiz #
359,146
Updated
Dec 03 21
# Qns
10
Difficulty
Average
Avg Score
7 / 10
Plays
836
Awards
Top 35% Quiz
- -
Question 1 of 10
1. A classic example of a dangling participle or misplaced modifier is this one, offered by Strunk & White in "The Elements of Style":

"Wondering irresolutely what to do next, the clock struck twelve."

Why is this sentence wrong?
Hint


Question 2 of 10
2. Prof. Mark Damen gives three very good examples of dangling modifiers in chapter 10 of his "A Guide to Writing in History and Classics" (2002). Which of these is the lone sentence that is correct? Hint


Question 3 of 10
3. Here is a note I received: "After reading what the editors go through to edit a quiz and make it acceptable, it is really amazing that they are so productive!"

While I agree with the sentiment, what could be done to make the misplaced modifier in this sentence not so misplaced -- ignoring any other possible errors in the sentence?
Hint


Question 4 of 10
4. In "The New York Times", David Brooks wrote: "If elected, Obama's main opposition will not come from Republicans."

Is this quote an example of a misplaced modifier?


Question 5 of 10
5. "Hopefully, the sun will be shining on our picnic tomorrow."

Although some grammarians contend this is wrong, others disagree. What kind of word is "hopefully" when used in this way, set apart from the rest of the sentence?
Hint


Question 6 of 10
6. The word "only" is often misplaced in English usage. Imagine this scenario:

As the curmudgeonly ruler of an island country, I don't like whipper-snappers voting in elections, so I have passed a law banning youngsters under 30 from the polls. Which of these sentences will best convey my meaning?
Hint


Question 7 of 10
7. "The sky being blue and cloudless, today is a good day for our picnic!"

Does this sentence present another case of a misplaced modifier? (Read carefully, please.)


Question 8 of 10
8. Another classic example of a misplaced modifier is a one-liner from the comedic movie "Animal Crackers" (1930). Groucho Marx says:

"One morning I shot an elephant in my pajamas. How he got into my pajamas I'll never know."

What is the misplaced modifier here that makes this so funny?
Hint


Question 9 of 10
9. I found an amusing example of a misplaced modifier when watching a silent movie starring Buster Keaton. As the young hero eloped with the farmer's daughter, he stole a horse and rode away, and a hired hand yelled this warning: "He's running away to get married with your horse!"

What does it sound like the hired hand said?
Hint


Question 10 of 10
10. We'll end with one more example from "The New York Times", on the very subject of misplaced modifiers. Philip B. Corbett writes:

"Danglers come in many forms. Most often, the problem involves a descriptive phrase at the beginning of a sentence, referring to a noun or pronoun that follows. Here's the key: that noun or pronoun should come immediately after the descriptive phrase. If not, the description 'dangles,' the connection is sloppy or obscure, and the reader may be momentarily confused. Once recognized, a writer or editor can easily fix the dangler, and the result is a clearer, sharper sentence."

Which sentence, in fact, has the very sort of dangler Corbett is talking about?
Hint



(Optional) Create a Free FunTrivia ID to save the points you are about to earn:

arrow Select a User ID:
arrow Choose a Password:
arrow Your Email:




Most Recent Scores
Today : Guest 174: 3/10
Oct 28 2024 : Guest 198: 6/10

Score Distribution

quiz
Quiz Answer Key and Fun Facts
1. A classic example of a dangling participle or misplaced modifier is this one, offered by Strunk & White in "The Elements of Style": "Wondering irresolutely what to do next, the clock struck twelve." Why is this sentence wrong?

Answer: The clock couldn't be wondering; the speaker is!

Assuming this is not a surreal novel about an anthropomorphic clock, we have to fix this sentence! As Strunk & White put it, "A participial phrase at the beginning of a sentence must refer to the grammatical subject." Otherwise, it is misplaced or dangling! We might rephrase in one of several ways:

"As I wondered irresolutely what to do next, the clock struck twelve."
"Wondering irresolutely what to do next, I heard the clock strike twelve."

Strunk & White give another "ludicrous" example: "Being in a dilapidated condition, I was able to buy the house very cheap." Now just who or what is supposed to be dilapidated?

The above selections were from the third edition, although the publisher Bartelby has the entire text of the first edition of "The Elements of Style" online. But it wouldn't hurt to purchase a copy of a later edition to keep handy when you are writing quizzes, school papers, business reports, or anything else important! LibriVox also has an audio recording available.
2. Prof. Mark Damen gives three very good examples of dangling modifiers in chapter 10 of his "A Guide to Writing in History and Classics" (2002). Which of these is the lone sentence that is correct?

Answer: The girl, no longer running in the park, realized she had lost her way.

Why are the other three choices wrong? Ask yourself: What is being whipped, the cook or the egg? Who is holding the money, the robber or the policeman? And while it is amusing to imagine the footballer flitting gaily from flower to flower, I suspect he was sitting still as he watched the bee gather up pollen.

A better to way to write the sentence about the robber, for example, might be, "The robber, still holding the money in his hand, ran from the policeman."

By the way, Damon's entire "Guide" can be found online at the Utah State University website, and it is well worth reading.
3. Here is a note I received: "After reading what the editors go through to edit a quiz and make it acceptable, it is really amazing that they are so productive!" While I agree with the sentiment, what could be done to make the misplaced modifier in this sentence not so misplaced -- ignoring any other possible errors in the sentence?

Answer: Change "it's really amazing" to "I'm really amazed"

While in written English it is better not to use contractions, eliminating them will not solve the problem with the misplaced modifier, nor will changing the preposition. Ask yourself, "who did the reading?" It was the speaker, so the long phrase beginning with "after reading" needs to modify a noun or pronoun referring to a person. "After reading what the editors go through, I am really amazed" would be acceptable.

Similarly, you would want to write, "After reading the newspaper, I finished my breakfast" rather than "After reading the newspaper, my breakfast was finished." You may notice that many times a misplaced modifier appears when the speaker needs to identify himself as the actor in a sentence rather than use passive voice or "it is". So don't hide behind impersonal constructions; be bold!
4. In "The New York Times", David Brooks wrote: "If elected, Obama's main opposition will not come from Republicans." Is this quote an example of a misplaced modifier?

Answer: Yes

The subject of the sentence is "Obama's main opposition", not "Obama", and so the noun that the phrase "If elected" modifies is "opposition". The point Brooks was trying to make is that, should Obama be elected, he would have more trouble with fellow Democrats with Republicans. Perhaps Brooks could have written, "If Obama is elected, his main opposition will not come from Republicans."

The quote is from David Brooks, "Talking Versus Doing", published in "The New York Times" (20 May 2008).
5. "Hopefully, the sun will be shining on our picnic tomorrow." Although some grammarians contend this is wrong, others disagree. What kind of word is "hopefully" when used in this way, set apart from the rest of the sentence?

Answer: disjunct

Other disjuncts, often sentence adverbials, are such words as honestly, unfortunately, clearly, in my opinion, and so forth. Many grammarians, including the venerable William Strunk, believe that "hopefully" should not be used this way. After all, the sun is not full of hope; the speaker is full of hope, so "hopefully" is an adverb just dangling, not attached to any adjective or verb to modify. (The correct sentence would then be, "I hope the sun will..." or some such.) Others say it is like "unfortunately" and modifies the sentence as a whole, just as "regrettably" does here: "Regrettably, we must decline your invitation." Some grammarians have further argued that just as one uses "regrettably" rather than "regretfully", one should use "hopeably" rather than "hopefully", but that nonce word has never caught on.
6. The word "only" is often misplaced in English usage. Imagine this scenario: As the curmudgeonly ruler of an island country, I don't like whipper-snappers voting in elections, so I have passed a law banning youngsters under 30 from the polls. Which of these sentences will best convey my meaning?

Answer: Only persons aged 30 and over can vote in elections.

Although you may see all those sentences plus others I cannot imagine, the only one that conveys the sense intended in the scenario is "Only persons aged 30 and over can vote". If you write "Persons aged 30 and over can only vote", you are suggesting that they can vote and do nothing else. If you write "Persons aged 30 and over can vote only in elections", you are suggesting that persons under 30 may vote in elections but in no other process" (which actually makes no sense). "Only in elections can persons aged 30 and over vote" would be another way to convey this last nonsensical idea.

By the way, I have noticed that French writers are more careful about the placement of "only" and other such adverbs than English writers, and that the misplacement really changes the meaning of the sentence. Learning to read another language makes one sensitive to that sort of thing!
7. "The sky being blue and cloudless, today is a good day for our picnic!" Does this sentence present another case of a misplaced modifier? (Read carefully, please.)

Answer: No

This is an example of an absolute construction. The participial phrase "being blue and cloudless" modifies "sky", and is correctly placed to do so. The entire phrase "The sky being blue and cloudless" is the absolute clause, which is generally only used in writing and difficult to explain except by example. Here are three examples from "Descriptive English Grammar" by House and Harman:

"The dance being over, we left."
"The teacher being absent, we had no school yesterday."
"Weather permitting, we shall go tomorrow."

So what we have here is, I hope, not a failure to communicate, but a clause that is set apart from the rest of the sentence. It modifies the sentence as a whole, rather than any particular noun, so it is not erroneously attached. Grammarian William Strunk did not care for these, and I share his opinion, but they are not misplaced modifiers.
###
By the way, "The sky's being..." would not be correct in the above sentence as being is NOT a gerund in the sentence above. Now, if I had written, "The sky's being blue is a good reason to have a picnic", then I would need an apostrophe.

This sentence from Edith Wharton's "The Age of Innocence" is also correct: "'The darling!' thought Newland Archer, his glance flitting back to the young girl with the lilies-of-the-valley." It would still be correct if Wharton had written, "His glance flitting back to the young girl, Newton thought..."
8. Another classic example of a misplaced modifier is a one-liner from the comedic movie "Animal Crackers" (1930). Groucho Marx says: "One morning I shot an elephant in my pajamas. How he got into my pajamas I'll never know." What is the misplaced modifier here that makes this so funny?

Answer: in my pajamas

Why is this funny? Although normally we would understand that that hunter was in his pajamas, the misplaced modifier does in fact suggest that the elephant was wearing the pajamas. The prepositional phrase "in my pajamas" is an adjectival phrase that modifies the noun or pronoun closest to it, which is "elephant" rather than "I". To write this correctly, one might choose: "One morning while I was still in my pajamas, I shot an elephant." I must confess I like the funny but wrong phrasing better, but I don't recommend using it to write a paper for school or a quiz for Fun Trivia!
9. I found an amusing example of a misplaced modifier when watching a silent movie starring Buster Keaton. As the young hero eloped with the farmer's daughter, he stole a horse and rode away, and a hired hand yelled this warning: "He's running away to get married with your horse!" What does it sound like the hired hand said?

Answer: Buster and the horse are getting married!

It is possible that the writer of the intertitle thought to make a joke like the famous one about Groucho Marx shooting an elephant in his pajamas (how the beast got in them, we'll never know). It's also possible that s/he just wasn't aware of the mistake.

A more correct way to write this sentence might be: "He's run off with your horse to marry your daughter!" or better yet, "He stole your horse, and he's run off to marry your daughter, too!" I also found it strange that the hired hand seemed more worried about the horse than the daughter!
10. We'll end with one more example from "The New York Times", on the very subject of misplaced modifiers. Philip B. Corbett writes: "Danglers come in many forms. Most often, the problem involves a descriptive phrase at the beginning of a sentence, referring to a noun or pronoun that follows. Here's the key: that noun or pronoun should come immediately after the descriptive phrase. If not, the description 'dangles,' the connection is sloppy or obscure, and the reader may be momentarily confused. Once recognized, a writer or editor can easily fix the dangler, and the result is a clearer, sharper sentence." Which sentence, in fact, has the very sort of dangler Corbett is talking about?

Answer: "Once recognized, a writer or editor can easily fix the dangler..."

Corbett made this mistake on purpose. "WAIT! IT'S A TRICK!" he writes. "That sentence has a classic dangler! The [participial] phrase 'once recognized' doesn't refer to what immediately follows, 'a writer or editor.'" His solution? "Once recognized, a dangler is usually easy to fix, and the result is a clearer, sharper sentence."

Corbett's article, "Left Dangling", was published in "The New York Times" on 15 May 2008.
Source: Author gracious1

This quiz was reviewed by FunTrivia editor looney_tunes before going online.
Any errors found in FunTrivia content are routinely corrected through our feedback system.
10/31/2024, Copyright 2024 FunTrivia, Inc. - Report an Error / Contact Us