14. Lou Gehrig should have been the undisputed home run leader in the American League in 1931. Instead, he finished in a tie with Babe Ruth. What incident caused him to lose sole possession of the title?
From Quiz Unbelievable But True Sports Events
Answer:
A base-running error
On April 26, 1931, the Yankees were playing the Washington Senators. Gehrig came to bat in the top of the first inning, with one out and the Yankees' shortstop, Lyn Lary, on first. The "Iron Horse" hit a terrific shot into the deepest part of centerfield. The ball landed in the stands for a home run, then bounced back out, and was caught by outfielder Harry Rice. Lary, who was running the bases, happened to glance toward the outfield just as Rice caught the ball. Rice, thinking quickly, fired the ball back into infield as if it were still in play. Lary assumed the ball was caught, and that he was out. He stopped at third, then sauntered into the Yankees dugout. Gehrig, however, continued running and crossed home plate. The umpire ruled that he was out for having passed Lary on the base path. The play was scored as a triple, instead of a home run, and that's why Gehrig had to share the home run title.