FREE! Click here to Join FunTrivia. Thousands of games, quizzes, and lots more!
Fun Trivia
Home: Questions and Answers Forum
Answers to 100,000 Fascinating Questions
Welcome to FunTrivia's Question & Answer forum!

Search All Questions


Please cite any factual claims with citation links or references from authoritative sources. Editors continuously recheck submissions and claims.

Archived Questions

Goto Qn #


When and who decided it to be 18 holes for a golf course?

Question #148833. Asked by Philip_Eno.
Last updated Mar 22 2022.
Originally posted Mar 16 2022 1:03 PM.

Related Trivia Topics: Sports  
wellenbrecher star
Answer has 3 votes
wellenbrecher star
20 year member
650 replies

Answer has 3 votes.
It dates back to 1842 when The Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews laid down in his Rules an 18 hole round, although the course did not even consist of 18 holes. It had only 10 holes of which 8 were played twice to produce a round of 18.

link https://www.scottishgolfhistory.org/origin-of-golf-terms/18-hole-round/

Mar 16 2022, 1:57 PM
avatar
elburcher star
Answer has 2 votes
elburcher star
24 year member
1523 replies avatar

Answer has 2 votes.
It seems it started at St Andrew's and by copying 18 holes has been perpetuated...
In the beginning, there was St. Andrews. And this old course that is most appropriately named THE Old Course had 18 holes. Well, near the beginning it had 18 holes, that is. And eventually, other courses were copycats.

So how did St. Andrews come to have 18 holes? There must have been some special Scottish reason for this, right? Wrong.

link https://www.golfdigest.com/story/did-you-know-why-does-a-golf-course-have-18-holes

Response last updated by elburcher on Mar 16 2022.
Mar 16 2022, 2:02 PM
avatar
AyatollahK star
Answer has 26 votes
Currently Best Answer
AyatollahK star
17 year member
715 replies avatar

Answer has 26 votes.

Currently voted the best answer.
I already voted for the responses above, but this really needs more explanation. Yes, the standard is 18 holes because of St. Andrews, but it actually wasn't that everyone decided to copy St. Andrews. In 1860, after the club pro at St. Andrews (who was considered to be the best golfer in Scotland) died the year before, another course (Prestwick, whose club pro was Old Tom Morris, who had also built the 12-hole course -- and who thought he was now the best golfer in Scotland) decided to organize a tournament to determine the best golfer, which it called The Open (now sometimes called the British Open). Basically, the tournament consisted of three trips around Prestwick in one day (thus, 36 holes), and to encourage people to come back, the tournament had a rule that, if anyone won the championship belt three years in a row, he could keep it and be proclaimed the best golfer in Scotland. The tournament generally came down to a battle between Morris and Willie Park, Sr. from St. Andrews (Morris won four and Park won three of the first eight). But then Tom Morris's 17-year-old son, called Young Tom Morris, started playing in the 9th tournament, and he immediately won it three straight years. End of tournament, we now know who the best golfer in Scotland is, thanks for coming, have a nice life.

Except. . .

Golfers had liked the tournament. A lot. And they didn't like the fact that there wasn't one the next year. So there was a meeting called between the governing bodies of the three premier courses in Scotland: Prestwick (12 holes), St. Andrews (18 holes), and Edinburgh (who played at but didn't own an 8-hole course called Musselburgh, where they had moved when their 5-hole course at Leith Links became overcrowded). The three groups decided to contribute for a new trophy and to rotate the tournament between them in the order Prestwick, St. Andrews, Edinburgh. But how to make it fair when they all had different numbers of holes? The solution was clear -- standardize the tournament at 36 holes, which would mean building an extra hole at Musselburgh, and then play three rounds at Prestwick, two rounds at St. Andrews, and four rounds at Musselburgh. And that's exactly what happened from 1872 to 1889. But, as the tournament became more popular, all three groups realized that it was easier to play two rounds in one day at St. Andrews than three rounds in one day at Prestwick or four rounds in one day at Musselburgh. So Prestwick bought more land and had Old Tom Morris build six more holes in 1882, making it the same size as St. Andrews. Now, starting in 1884, it only had to be played twice, just like St. Andrews.

But Musselburgh couldn't get any more land. So the Edinburgh Company bought its own land after the 1889 tournament at Musselburgh ended in darkness and built a new course, which it called Muirfield. It had Old Tom Morris design the course at 18 holes, so it would match both St. Andrews and Prestwick. Thus, The Open would now rotate among three 18-hole courses. And other venues that were building courses realized that they had to build 18-hole courses to be able to host The Open, which became a real issue when the Edinburgh Company had to boost the prize pot for 1892 from £ 25 to £ 100 (with a winners share of £ 30) to fight off competition from the jilted Musselburgh, which planned to hold a tournament on the same date and offer a prize pot of £ 30. (To afford that, Edinburgh increased the tournament to two days, or 72 holes, and it has remained there ever since.)

The prize money escalation forced the organizers to allow other courses to host in return for a financial contribution, albeit with the stipulation that they had to be 18 holes as well. And sure enough, first St. George's in England (built in England at the same time as Muirfield and soon designated Royal St. George's) and then Royal Liverpool in England (built by Old Tom Morris' brother and expanded to 18 holes even before Prestwick) joined the rotation. The idea that a meaningful tournament had to be played on an 18-hole course and consist of 72 holes became standard. But it wasn't just to imitate St. Andrews but rather that the three courses had to standardize the number of holes played. [For what it's worth, The Open remained a two-day tournament with 36 holes per day until 1926.]

link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Open_Championship

Mar 16 2022, 6:02 PM
davejacobs
Answer has 0 votes
davejacobs
22 year member
956 replies

Answer has 0 votes.
The question still remains, in my mind, as to why 18 was thought to be the perfect number of holes for a round, rather than say 15, 20, or any other number. What was the psychology of those early players?,

Mar 20 2022, 10:25 AM
avatar
AyatollahK star
Answer has 1 vote
AyatollahK star
17 year member
715 replies avatar

Answer has 1 vote.
davejacobs: Look at the early courses in existence in 1860: Leith Links (where the rules of golf were originally developed -- 5 holes, played twice); Musselburgh (7 holes, expanded to 8 in 1838); Prestwick (12 holes); Carnoustie (10 holes); North Berwick (6 holes); Kinghorn (9 holes). And then there were two established courses that predated 1600: Montrose (25 holes!) and the oldest, St. Andrews (22 holes, reduced to 18 in 1764). So the truth is that people in the early-to-mid 1800s seemed to look at 8-12 holes as the ideal for a round. When Royal Liverpool was built in 1869, it had 9 holes, then almost immediately expanded to 12.

Course size was only standardized after 1870 due to The Open, when it proved easier to play 18 holes twice in one day than to play 12 holes three times or 9 holes four times. Nothing deeper than that!

Mar 20 2022, 5:25 PM
avatar
elburcher star
Answer has 1 vote
elburcher star
24 year member
1523 replies avatar

Answer has 1 vote.
To add to AyatollahK's answer above...
in 1872 The Open was a 36 hole event played at Prestwick 3 rounds of 12, 1873 The Open now at St Andrews, still 36 holes played as two rounds of 18. Lastly, In 1874 having moved to Musselburgh it was 36 holes played as 4 rounds of 9. The reason given for the change to 18 was that St Andrews was 18, others were taking St Andrews lead, plus the Royal and Ancient Golf Club was based at St Andrews. In 1881 Prestwick joined others and standardized their course at 18 holes. So, it seems to be pretty much a case of follow the leader with St Andrews being the leader.

Mar 22 2022, 7:55 AM
free email trivia FREE! Get a new mixed Fun Trivia quiz each day in your email. It's a fun way to start your day!


arrow Your Email Address:

Sign in or Create Free User ID to participate in the discussion

Related FunTrivia Quizzes

play quiz Classic Golf Holes
(Golf Courses)
play quiz Holes
(Holes .)
play quiz Holes
(Sachar, Louis)

Return to FunTrivia
"Ask FunTrivia" strives to offer the best answers possible to trivia questions. We ask our submitters to thoroughly research questions and provide sources where possible. Feel free to post corrections or additions. This is server B184.