FREE! Click here to Join FunTrivia. Thousands of games, quizzes, and lots more!
Fun Trivia
Home: Questions and Answers Forum
Answers to 100,000 Fascinating Questions
Welcome to FunTrivia's Question & Answer forum!

Search All Questions


Please cite any factual claims with citation links or references from authoritative sources. Editors continuously recheck submissions and claims.

Archived Questions

Goto Qn #


What is the origin of the riddle involving two paths, The Liar and The Truthful Person?

Question #97681. Asked by jimmycarlos.
Last updated Jul 02 2021.

avatar
BRY2K star
Answer has 10 votes
Currently Best Answer
BRY2K star
17 year member
3707 replies avatar

Answer has 10 votes.

Currently voted the best answer.
The truth/lie riddle :

You have two identical paths before you. One leads to your goal, the other to certain doom. There is a guardian of some sort beside each path, usually a troll or gargoyle or soldier. You are informed that one of these soldiers always tells the truth, while the other always tells lies, but you don’t know which is which and you can only ask them ONE question.

The Liar Paradox has been discussed continually in philosophy since the middle of the 4th century BCE. The most ancient attribution is to Eubulides of Miletus. He said, "A man says that he is lying. Is what he says true or false?" An ancient gravestone on the Greek Island of Cos was reported by Athenaeus to contain this poem about the paradox:

O Stranger: Philetas of Cos am I,
'Twas the Liar who made me die,
And the bad nights caused thereby.
Theophrastus, Aristotle's successor, wrote three papyrus rolls about the Liar Paradox, and the Stoic philosopher Chrysippus wrote six, but their contents are lost in the sands of time.

In the New Testament of the Bible, Saint Paul warned, "One of themselves, even a prophet of their own, said the Cretans are always liars." Paul, however, gave no indication he recognized anything paradoxical about the Cretan's remark.

There are many versions of the Paradox in addition to Buridan's and the Liar generated from. Some liar paradoxes begin with sets of two or more sentences:

The following sentence is true.
The previous sentence is false.

Read more about the logic and history behind the paradox/riddle here:
link http://www.iep.utm.edu/p/par-liar.htm#H1

Response last updated by gtho4 on Jul 02 2021.
Jul 18 2008, 8:39 PM
avatar
zbeckabee star
Answer has 9 votes
zbeckabee star
Moderator
19 year member
11752 replies avatar

Answer has 9 votes.
The Epimenides paradox should be mentioned, a variation of the liar's paradox dating back to 6 BC.

link http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/alabaster/A471449

link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epimenides

link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epimenides_paradox

Jul 18 2008, 10:37 PM
free email trivia FREE! Get a new mixed Fun Trivia quiz each day in your email. It's a fun way to start your day!


arrow Your Email Address:

Sign in or Create Free User ID to participate in the discussion

Related FunTrivia Quizzes

play quiz One Person's Weed Is Another Person's Wildflower
( Thematic Fun)
play quiz Songs involving crime
(Crime and Punishment in Songs)
play quiz How Many Career Paths Can YOU Take?
( Occupational Trivia)

Return to FunTrivia
"Ask FunTrivia" strives to offer the best answers possible to trivia questions. We ask our submitters to thoroughly research questions and provide sources where possible. Feel free to post corrections or additions. This is server B184.