20. "Rashomon" (1950)
Three men take shelter from the rain and recount a dreadful story of rape and murder that two of them witnessed. They eventually notice something has been abandoned in the shelter.
What do the three men find in the shelter?
From Quiz What's In A Film? The Films of Akira Kurosawa
Answer:
A baby
The story of the rape and murder is told from various perspectives, one of which is that of the murder victim's ghost. The stories are incongruent, and since each witness has a reason to lie, the viewer is never really sure who to believe. Although Kurosawa seems to be saying something rather cynical about human selfishness, when the baby is found and taken in by one of the three men (a poor woodcutter), he counterbalances the bleak vision with a sense of hope in humankind.
"Rashomon", which was based on two short stories by Japanese writer Ryūnosuke Akutagawa, starred Kurosawa regulars Toshiro Mifune, Takashi Shimura, and Minoru Chiaki. It was a huge critical success and really made Kurosawa's reputation abroad. It's since become one his most discussed films and a classic of cinema. It was remade in 1974 as "The Outrage", a Western which starred Edward G. Robinson and Paul Newman.
About the red herrings: an umbrella would have come in handy, a dagger is a vital part of the story, and I just threw the pig in for fun.