18. As a delegate at the Democratic Convention in 1860, whom did Butler vote for, calling him "a statesman of national fame" and a war hero who would put the interests of the country over the interests of his section?
From Quiz 'Beast' Butler
Answer:
Jefferson Davis
Ironically, Davis became president of the Confederacy. His and Butler's friendship broke down to the point where both threatened the other with execution without trial if captured.
After enduring much criticism for having voted for Davis, Butler explained:
"With the facts before me, and impressing me with the conviction that the nomination of Judge Douglas could not be made with any hope of safety to the Democratic party, what was I to do? Yielding to your preferences, I voted seven times for Judge Douglas, although my judgment told me that my votes were worse than useless, as they gave him an appearance of strength in the convention which I felt he had not in the party.
I then looked about me ... [and] saw a statesman of national fame, who had led his regiment to victory at Buena Vista, a Democrat with whom I disagreed in some things, but with whom I could act in most-loving his country first, his section next, but just to all ... I thought such a man worthy of the compliment of a vote from Massachusetts; therefore I threw my vote for Jefferson Davis of Mississippi. I make no apology for that vote. I believe I was guided by an intelligent view of the situation."
Source: Howard Nash, "Stormy Petrel The Life and Times of General Benjamin F. Butler 1818-1893" (Rutherford, New Jersey: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 1969), 63-64.