FREE! Click here to Join FunTrivia. Thousands of games, quizzes, and lots more!
Quiz about Ten Gruesome Folk Songs
Quiz about Ten Gruesome Folk Songs

Ten Gruesome Folk Songs Trivia Quiz


My quiz "Ten 'Killer' Songs" had some people calling for more! Unfortunately I can't find many more rock and pop songs about murder, so here are ten grisly tales from British folk songs. I'll give you the story, see if you know the ending.

A multiple-choice quiz by mutchisman. Estimated time: 9 mins.
  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Quizzes
  4. »
  5. Music Trivia
  6. »
  7. International Music
  8. »
  9. UK Music

Author
mutchisman
Time
9 mins
Type
Multiple Choice
Quiz #
271,986
Updated
Dec 03 21
# Qns
10
Difficulty
Difficult
Avg Score
4 / 10
Plays
1554
Awards
Top 20% Quiz
- -
Question 1 of 10
1. "Little Sir Hugh" from Steeleye Span's "Commoner's Crown" album is a song that starts off jolly enough;

"Four and twenty bonny bonny boys playing at the ball
Along came little Sir Hugh, he played with them all."

However, things take a turn for the worse when Hugh's lack of ball control means he has to retrieve the ball from the other side of a castle wall. Big mistake, the lady of the castle is not best pleased:

"She took him by the milk white hand, led him to the hall
Till they came to a stone chamber where no one could hear him call
She sat him on a golden chair, she gave him sugar sweet
She lay him on a dressing board and..."

What do you think comes next?


Hint


Question 2 of 10
2. "Cruel Sister" from the Pentangle album of the same name is a tale of sibling rivalry gone mad. Two sisters who never really got on and both wanted the same man. The one sister pushes the other into the sea and watches her drown, families eh?

"She took her sister by the hand
And led her down to the North Sea strand.
And as they stood on the windy shore
The dark girl threw her sister o'er."

How do you think her murderous actions are uncovered?
Hint


Question 3 of 10
3. Now for a ghost story; "The Suffolk Miracle" is a much loved song, the version I refer to can be found on Jim Moray's excellent debut album "Sweet England.

A squire disapproves of his daughter's suitor. He sends his daughter away to live with relatives. While she is gone her young man dies (of a broken heart according to the father, hmmm). Some months later the 'young man' turns up where the daughter is staying and bids her to come with him back to her father's house.

"She looked out of her window clear
And saw her true love on her father's mare,
Saying, "Your mother's orders you must obey
And your father's anger to satisfy.""

On the journey back home the daughter gives her young man a present.
To cut a long story short, the grave is discovered, the girl wants to know how the young man died and when the body is recovered it is bearing the present given by the girl!

What was discovered on the body?

Hint


Question 4 of 10
4. "Sheath and Knife" is a song with some very disturbing variations; this version is from Eliza Carthy's "Heat, Light and Sound" album.

A young girl becomes pregnant and, unable to cope with the shame, asks her sister to kill her. Well what you going to do...?

How do the two sisters plan to stage the pregnant one's death?
Hint


Question 5 of 10
5. Nic Jones's sad tale of "Miles Weatherhill" is a song about a real life event. In 1867 a man named Miles Weatherhill broke into a vicarage and in a fit of rage killed the vicar, the vicar's daughter and a servant.

"Four loaded pistols, a fit of frenzy,
Miles to the vicarage went forthwith,
And with a weapon wounded the master,
And he shot the maiden named Jane Smith."

What had made Miles so angry?



Hint


Question 6 of 10
6. Picture a cosy scene; a young lover and his lass sitting under a willow tree, she falls gently asleep, ahhh. No not 'ahhh' but aaarrrghh!
He commits bloody murder upon her.

"I stabbed her with a dagger,
Which was a bloody knife,
I threw her in the river,
Which was a dreadful sight."

These lines are taken from Nick Cave's version of "Down by the Willow Garden", a song that has been covered many, many times.
How does the killer know the girl will fall asleep?
Hint


Question 7 of 10
7. "The Maid Freed from the Gallows" also known as "The Prickly Bush" is a story of a girl about to be hung (we know not why) who hopes that the hangman is open to bribery.
She procrastinates as various people arrive one by one to watch her hang;

"O Hangman, stay thy hand,
And stay it for a while,
For I fancy I see my father
A coming across the yonder stile.
O, father, have you my gold?
And can you set me free?
Or are you come to see me hung?
All on the gallows tree?"

Who comes up with something to bribe the hangman?
Hint


Question 8 of 10
8. The folk song "The Cruel Mother" has many variations all on the theme of infanticide, guilt and retribution. The version here is the one sung by June Tabor.

An unmarried lady gives birth to twins and promptly kills them and hides the bodies.

"She took a knife so keen and sharp,
She pierced it through each tender heart.
And she's dug a hole all beneath the tree
And she's buried them where none might see."

Some while later, the babies appear as ghosts and prophesise the lady's future.

What fate awaits her?

Hint


Question 9 of 10
9. There are some very gory tales in Scottish folk songs. The tale of "Daughter Doris" has some particularly nasty passages, this version is told by Hamish Henderson on Martyn Bennett's "Grit" album.

This is a laugh-a-minute story of a king's daughter whose mother dies. She does not get on with her step-mother and the king throws his daughter out. She has a brief moment of happiness when she meets and marries a soldier. As soon as she finds she is with child, he leaves to go off to war. She is now homeless, so returns to her father's castle and throws herself at his mercy.
So how does he treat her?
Hint


Question 10 of 10
10. There are several versions of the ballad called "Lankin", sometimes "Lamkin", but all have very graphic descriptions of murders. This version is from Steeleye Span's "Commoner's Crown" album and is called "Long Lankin".
A lord of the manor has swindled Lankin who extracts bloody revenge by first killing the lord's baby (I'll spare you that bit) and then killing his wife, (he is assisted in these murders by the family's nurse);

"Down the stairs the lady came, thinking no harm
Lankin he stood ready to catch her in his arms.
There was blood all in the kitchen
There was blood all in the hall
There was blood all in the parlour
Where my lady she did fall."

Nice!

What fate awaits Lankin?
Hint



(Optional) Create a Free FunTrivia ID to save the points you are about to earn:

arrow Select a User ID:
arrow Choose a Password:
arrow Your Email:




Quiz Answer Key and Fun Facts
1. "Little Sir Hugh" from Steeleye Span's "Commoner's Crown" album is a song that starts off jolly enough; "Four and twenty bonny bonny boys playing at the ball Along came little Sir Hugh, he played with them all." However, things take a turn for the worse when Hugh's lack of ball control means he has to retrieve the ball from the other side of a castle wall. Big mistake, the lady of the castle is not best pleased: "She took him by the milk white hand, led him to the hall Till they came to a stone chamber where no one could hear him call She sat him on a golden chair, she gave him sugar sweet She lay him on a dressing board and..." What do you think comes next?

Answer: Stabbed him like a sheep

I don't know whether the lady was just taking a nap or maybe watching the "Eastenders" omnibus; either way she did not like being disturbed. Just for good measure she disposed of poor Hugh's body by throwing it down a well.
A bit of a harsh punishment but he won't ever kick his ball onto her bedding plants again!
"Commoner's Crown" was released in Britain in 1975 and reached number 21 in the album charts.
"Little Sir Hugh" has its origins in the murder of Little Saint Hugh of Lincoln who was supposedly killed sometime in the 13th century.
2. "Cruel Sister" from the Pentangle album of the same name is a tale of sibling rivalry gone mad. Two sisters who never really got on and both wanted the same man. The one sister pushes the other into the sea and watches her drown, families eh? "She took her sister by the hand And led her down to the North Sea strand. And as they stood on the windy shore The dark girl threw her sister o'er." How do you think her murderous actions are uncovered?

Answer: The dead sister's body is made into a harp which then tells the tale

Oh the old 'find a body on the shore and make a harp out of it' routine;

"Two minstrels walked along the strand
And saw the maiden float to land.
They made a harp of her breastbone,
Whose sound would melt a heart of stone.
They took three locks of her yellow hair,
And with them strung the harp so rare."

They take the harp to the wedding feast and the harp gives the game away!

"Cruel sister" is a medieval song with many variants, it is sometimes known as "The Twa Sisters". The Pentangle album was first released in 1970. "Cruel Sister" can also be found on several Pentangle compilation albums.
3. Now for a ghost story; "The Suffolk Miracle" is a much loved song, the version I refer to can be found on Jim Moray's excellent debut album "Sweet England. A squire disapproves of his daughter's suitor. He sends his daughter away to live with relatives. While she is gone her young man dies (of a broken heart according to the father, hmmm). Some months later the 'young man' turns up where the daughter is staying and bids her to come with him back to her father's house. "She looked out of her window clear And saw her true love on her father's mare, Saying, "Your mother's orders you must obey And your father's anger to satisfy."" On the journey back home the daughter gives her young man a present. To cut a long story short, the grave is discovered, the girl wants to know how the young man died and when the body is recovered it is bearing the present given by the girl! What was discovered on the body?

Answer: A handkerchief

Once again, all very believable but a good song nevertheless.

"Her father knowing this young man was dead
Caused every hair to stand on his head,
He wrung his hands and he wept full sore
But this young man's darling wept ten times more.

She arose, to the churchyard goes,
She riz the corpse that was lying once dead,
She riz the corpse that was nine months dead
With a holland handkerchief tied round his head."

The handkerchief was tied around a head wound; explain that one away, father!

Jim Moray's debut album "Sweet England" was released to critical acclaim in 2003. It won best album in the BBC Folk Awards for 2004.
4. "Sheath and Knife" is a song with some very disturbing variations; this version is from Eliza Carthy's "Heat, Light and Sound" album. A young girl becomes pregnant and, unable to cope with the shame, asks her sister to kill her. Well what you going to do...? How do the two sisters plan to stage the pregnant one's death?

Answer: Fabricate a hunting accident

The two sisters go out hunting early one morning. The pregnant girl scatters the hounds, hawks and her horse. She then makes a grave and then instructs her sister to, "Bend your bow and let your arrow fly".

Very sad; in many versions (not this one) the girl is made pregnant by her own brother.
5. Nic Jones's sad tale of "Miles Weatherhill" is a song about a real life event. In 1867 a man named Miles Weatherhill broke into a vicarage and in a fit of rage killed the vicar, the vicar's daughter and a servant. "Four loaded pistols, a fit of frenzy, Miles to the vicarage went forthwith, And with a weapon wounded the master, And he shot the maiden named Jane Smith." What had made Miles so angry?

Answer: The vicar refused him permission to court another of his servants

Miles Weatherhill had fallen for one of the vicar's servants. The vicar did not approve of the match and sent the servant girl back to her parents. Dispite various protestations, Miles was not allowed to see the girl and eventually he snapped. He was tried and convicted of murder and in 1868 was the last person to be publicly executed at Manchester jail.

This song appears on The Nic Jones album "Noah's Ark Trap".
6. Picture a cosy scene; a young lover and his lass sitting under a willow tree, she falls gently asleep, ahhh. No not 'ahhh' but aaarrrghh! He commits bloody murder upon her. "I stabbed her with a dagger, Which was a bloody knife, I threw her in the river, Which was a dreadful sight." These lines are taken from Nick Cave's version of "Down by the Willow Garden", a song that has been covered many, many times. How does the killer know the girl will fall asleep?

Answer: He has put something in the wine

"Down in a willow garden
Where me and my love did meet,
'Twas there we sat a courting
My love dropped off to sleep.
I had a bottle of the Burglar's wine
Which my true love did not know,
And so I poisoned that dear little girl
Down under the bank below."

In some versions the poison kills the girl but in this version the killer really meant business. He is hung for his pains.

This folk song is 'popular' (if that's the right word) on both sides of the Atlantic. It is usually claimed as an Appalachian folk song but its origins are probably Irish. People who have covered it in one version or another include Leadbelly, Pete Seeger and The Bachelors.
7. "The Maid Freed from the Gallows" also known as "The Prickly Bush" is a story of a girl about to be hung (we know not why) who hopes that the hangman is open to bribery. She procrastinates as various people arrive one by one to watch her hang; "O Hangman, stay thy hand, And stay it for a while, For I fancy I see my father A coming across the yonder stile. O, father, have you my gold? And can you set me free? Or are you come to see me hung? All on the gallows tree?" Who comes up with something to bribe the hangman?

Answer: Her true love

Well we never know what the poor girl has done but it seems all of her family are happy to watch her hang so it must have been something pretty bad.

"No, I've not brought thee gold,
And I can't set thee free;
But I have come to see thee hung
All on the gallows tree."

It is left to her true love to bring some gold and silver and save the day. Or does he? In most versions it is not made clear if the hangman takes the bribe or not and we're left 'hanging' about the outcome.

Perhaps the most famous version of this number is by Led Zeppelin on their third album; they called the song "Gallows Pole".
8. The folk song "The Cruel Mother" has many variations all on the theme of infanticide, guilt and retribution. The version here is the one sung by June Tabor. An unmarried lady gives birth to twins and promptly kills them and hides the bodies. "She took a knife so keen and sharp, She pierced it through each tender heart. And she's dug a hole all beneath the tree And she's buried them where none might see." Some while later, the babies appear as ghosts and prophesise the lady's future. What fate awaits her?

Answer: Seven years in Hell

"Babes, oh babes, come tell me true,
What death must I die for you?"
"For seven years you shall ring the bell,
For seven years you shall wait in Hell"

There are several variants but all finish with the seven years in Hell punishment. In Shirley Collins' version the pregnant girl is a minister's daughter. Steeleye Span comment in their sleeve notes that the song dates from a time "...before birth control, before the Social Services, before tranquillisers..."!
June Tabor's version can be found on her album "An Echo of Hooves".
9. There are some very gory tales in Scottish folk songs. The tale of "Daughter Doris" has some particularly nasty passages, this version is told by Hamish Henderson on Martyn Bennett's "Grit" album. This is a laugh-a-minute story of a king's daughter whose mother dies. She does not get on with her step-mother and the king throws his daughter out. She has a brief moment of happiness when she meets and marries a soldier. As soon as she finds she is with child, he leaves to go off to war. She is now homeless, so returns to her father's castle and throws herself at his mercy. So how does he treat her?

Answer: He cuts off her arms and legs

"So he takes his sword
And he cuts off her right arm.
"Is that sore? daughter Doris?" He asks
"Oh yes, father" she says "very!" He then proceeds to lop off her other limbs and for good measure her breasts. Doris cannot move and cannot feed her baby but somehow they get by and the boy grows up to avenge his mothers treatment.
According to the liner notes, "The story is an allegory about deceit, brutality, complicit victimisation and petty power struggles that go on in most families." Speak for youself mate!

The sad loss of Martyn Bennett to cancer in 2005 robbed Scotland of one of its great folk music innovaters. The Album "Grit", released a few months before his death contains recordings of traditional Scottish folk songs by various folk-singers married up to modern dance rhythms. It's a bit hit and miss to my ears but some tracks such as "Move", "Chanter" and especially "Rant" are brilliant.
10. There are several versions of the ballad called "Lankin", sometimes "Lamkin", but all have very graphic descriptions of murders. This version is from Steeleye Span's "Commoner's Crown" album and is called "Long Lankin". A lord of the manor has swindled Lankin who extracts bloody revenge by first killing the lord's baby (I'll spare you that bit) and then killing his wife, (he is assisted in these murders by the family's nurse); "Down the stairs the lady came, thinking no harm Lankin he stood ready to catch her in his arms. There was blood all in the kitchen There was blood all in the hall There was blood all in the parlour Where my lady she did fall." Nice! What fate awaits Lankin?

Answer: He is hanged

"Now Long Lankin shall be hanged
from the gallows oh so high,
And the false nurse shall be burned
in the fire close by."

Lankin is hung for murder, while the nurse's punishment is for 'petty treason'.

In some versions of this sorry tale the lord had first commisioned Lankin to build him a castle and then had refused to pay. The nurse also has some (unstated) grievance against the family.

I guess some of you would have expected Fairport Convention's "Matty Groves" in here. I would have loved to have put it in but I used it in another quiz, curses.

With grateful thanks to Rowena8482 for ideas and encouragement.
Source: Author mutchisman

This quiz was reviewed by FunTrivia editor ertrum before going online.
Any errors found in FunTrivia content are routinely corrected through our feedback system.
12/22/2024, Copyright 2024 FunTrivia, Inc. - Report an Error / Contact Us